Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Our freight bills are already audited!

When we speak to prospective customers, one thing we often hear is that they already have an outside firm review their bills prior to payment or that they review the bills themselves.  We explain that the majority of our audit of freight bills are done following audit and freight payment and that our audits still finds mistakes that have been overlooked.

Recently we received a refund from a carrier for one of our clients that is a great example of why there is value in having an additional audit after the bills have been paid.  Our client in Texas gave an LTL carrier a shipment going to Barbados.  This carrier is an multinational company with various operations including some that handle international shipments.  But their LTL operation only handles the domestic portion of a shipment destined to Barbados and those shipments show what port to move the freight to and the forwarding company that will handle the ocean freight.  The original bill of lading showed none of that information.  To further complicate matters, the B/L showed a third party billing address in Barbados (another no-no) and an account number for this carrier.

The shipment was picked up and moved into the carrier's system because the postal code used for Barbados is a five digit number exactly like our own ZIP code system.  So the carrier's computers routed this freight towards Virginia.  Ultimately the shipment was stopped in Pennsylvania and returned to our customer's plant in Texas, with  a note saying they could not deliver to Barbados.

The customer's freight payer originally rejected the bill asking the client to review the bill.  The customer, recognizing that they gave the shipment to the LTL carrier, authorized the payment of both the outbound bill and the return charges back to their factory.

With year's of experience, our auditor asked how the shipment even left the origin terminal since it should have been obvious at that point that they do not deliver to this foreign country. At that point, we expected to file a claim for refund for all of the charges less a fee they charge for returning shipments to a shipper from the origin point.  In speaking to a sales representative for the carrier, he learned that, in fact, the driver never should have picked the shipment up.  Had they noted the shipment was going to Barbados, their hand-held computer would have prevented the shipment from even entering their system.  Subsequently, we filed the claim for the total freight charges for both invoices.

Initially they refused to refund the bills, noting simply that someone at the shipper had authorized the charges both ways.  We again explained that the shipment never should have been picked up in the first place.  That brought about the refund check that we received.  Both the freight payment service and the customer themselves overlooked the driver's error that compounded the customer's own  mistake.  The customer had OK'd payment of the charges and the payment service acted accordingly.

We sent our customer the check for nearly $900.00; money they never would have recovered without our post-audit.

Give us a call today to discuss how we can begin recovering money you've overpaid to your carriers.  Our decades of experience can get to work for you too!

Learn more about our freight bill auditing service.



Thursday, May 24, 2012

Transporation's New Frontier



My family has long been in the transportation business in some form or another.  My dad began in the railroad carloading business in the late 1940's (where small shipments were loaded on to rail cars, a dying mode still competing with the burgeoning Less Than Truckload business).  From there he went on to working for various trucking companies in sales, then to managing a manufacturer's traffic and purchasing departments and finally starting his own consulting company, Jayanel Associates.  I took over the auditing and rate quoting services of that company in 1979, beginning Traffic Services of Cinti.

Further my maternal grandfather worked for the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Company and my wife's maternal grandfather worked for the Missouri Pacific Railroad.  In doing genealogy work for my family, I learned that my great-grandpa, also Joe Metz, an immigrant from Germany, was a "teamster" back when that was the actual job, driving a team of horses.  Another great-grandfather was a clerk for a railroad firm (not sure which one).

With all that history, my family has lived the arc of transportation advancements for over a century; from moving goods by horse & wagon, on to trains that trekked across the country, to the trucking business.  Last week, I visited my dad, now in his 80's, and told him about the latest in the movement of cargo - a private rocket cargo company which will carry goods from here on Earth up to the International Space Station.  I asked Dad if he'd ever thought he'd see such a thing and he replied, "Yes, in my Buck Rogers comic books!"  But the future has arrived and a California company called SpaceX launched the first private rocket into space.  It still needs to run through various tests before it may dock with the space station, but so far so good.  It's an interesting day and the freight bill auditor in me would like to audit that freight bill!

On a more down to earth matter - check with us for your freight bill auditing needs.  We specialize in reviewing your bills after they've been paid (whether by your personnel or by an outside audit & payment service).  We continue to find mistakes routinely occurring on carriers' freight bills and they're often overlooked.  We bring that overpaid money to you. 

Contact us today to see how you can begin saving too.

Friday, December 3, 2010

Year End "To Do" List - Have Your Freight Bills Audited!

As the year ends, businesses are making their year end "To Do" lists.  A primary one is to pull this year's files to place into storage.  This is the perfect time to begin what should be a routine throughout the year - have your freight bills reviewed again.  I noted in my earlier blog post that many companies assume they don't need an audit after their bills have been processed by a freight payment company.   The fact is, most of our post-audit work is following freight payment firms and we continue to find mistakes that are overlooked.

I'm surprised during this difficult economic period that more companies are not utilizing our services to bring cash back to them that they've already spent - and at no direct cost to them.  Our fee is on a contingency basis, a percentage of the collected refunds.  If we find nothing, there is no charge.  We can review bills back 180 days unless you have a longer time period stated in your agreements with your carriers. 

Once we've done our initial audit, we recommend that your freight bills be sent to us on a regular basis, generally quarterly.  We do have some clients though who have their freight payment companies send the paid bills to us directly.  Following our audit, we place them in storage boxes they've provided us.  When we return them to our clients, there's no need for their employees to do any further filing.

Visit our website today and learn more about how we can begin saving you money with our freight bill audit.  Our satisfied customers are happy they have utilized our services.  I believe you will be too.  Contact us now.

Friday, July 9, 2010

Why Should I Have My Freight Bills Reviewed Again?

Many businesses have their freight bills processed and paid by freight payment companies; reviewing the bills for errors, verifying Bill of Lading terms, and providing an accounting of the freight costs for them. Prospective customers often ask us why they should have the bills reviewed again since these processors have done the work already.

I respond that there is a dramatic difference between a pre-audit of the bills and our audit after the bills are paid. The constraints of processing a great volume of bills in a short period of time, necessitated by the limits imposed by carriers for paying bills, leaves little time for gathering information that may show that a bill is incorrect and an overcharge. Sometimes the pre-audit firm hasn't been given updated information that we subsequently receive. That leads to overcharges that have been overlooked because the pre-auditor is unaware of the change. And sometimes, it's just that people are fallible and miss mistakes that are there.

We point out to companies that they have nothing to lose and everything to gain. If the bill has been paid and overcharges exist, that money is rarely coming back without our audit. As we noted in an earlier blog post, money recovered for you goes straight to your bottom line. You know what your profit margins is and that money goes directly to your bottom line.

A carrier representative once asked if computers wouldn't put us out of business. I noted that as long as human beings were pressing the keys, mistakes will be made. And every time I think we have seen every way possible for errors to occur, someone comes up with another one.

Contact us today to learn more about how we can begin recovering overpayments you may have made.

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Updated Website Launched!

Yesterday, we launched our updated website, http://www.tscinti.com/. We look forwarded to the new site being a gateway for introducing more businesses to the valuable service we offer.

Thursday, November 12, 2009

The Check Was in the Mail!




I explain to clients that our freight bill auditing service is often a roll of the dice. We never know what we're going to find in an audit, nor do we know how quickly we will receive the refund check from their carrier. Most handle our overcharge claims routinely and are prompt in sending the client's refund or explaining why they disagree with our claim. When a carrier does decline a claim, we review it and if we disagree advise why they're mistaken.




I received a check this morning for nearly $7000 for a client for a claim we filed back in February. The customer had sent out some product without a proper description for the goods and mentioned the word "display" on their Bill of Lading. The shipment wasn't a display. It was their main product and merely had some additional corrugated cardboard they called a "wedge" that permitted the item to angle up on the store shelf.




The carrier replied that they had a rule about product shipped in cartons that are for display (much as you might see at a warehouse club). But that's not what these were. The carrier parried back, sending some photos of some of my client's shipments which were such displays. There was only one problem. The photos were not of these shipments, but some other unrelated item. The claim languished until we spoke with our client a few weeks ago and I went over the reasons their carrier was wrong.




Lo and behold, the check arrived in the mail! My client told me he knew about it a week ago, but wanted me to be surprised, and it was a nice one at that. At times, some of our work can be like a chess match and it's fun occasionally to match wits with a carrier and to prevail. This was one of those times.




And we got to send almost $7000 over to our customer, money they had already spent and now has come back to them. We're always looking for new bills to audit, and most of the bills we check are after they've been processed and paid by another outside payment and audit service. Give us a call if you'd like to start receiving refunds back on your freight bills too.




You can read more about our services here: http://www.tscinti.com/




Friday, May 29, 2009

Auditing EDI freight bills

Another big change in the thirty years I've been in business is the presentation of freight bills by EDI (Electronic Data Interchange). EDI came on the scene in the early 1990's and it's only been over the last several years that we've had more clients move to receiving their freight bills via EDI. Initially the few clients who had EDI bills, a number had their freight payment companies print out the bills, perhaps two or three to a page and we would audit from those printed pages. This wasn't something we had requested, it just happened to be what their procedure was.

Of course, printing the bills out defeated one of the advantages of using EDI; eliminating the use of paper. Some years ago, we had a software developer create an EDI bill reader for us that would permit us to see the data in a freight bill format. We could then audit the bills from the screen and print a "freight bill" to submit an overcharge from that copy. For those clients who sent us EDI bills, we would find mistakes, just as we do with actual paper freight bills. For a while, we did hav one client send us an Excel spreadsheet of their EDI bills and found mistakes on those bills as well.

We have talked with some clients to get their EDI data, but unfortunately, as is the case these days, it's not a priority.

This week though, in reviewing the payment info on the freight payment firms site for one client whose bills had dwindled down to just a few paper freight bills that we could audit. In checking payment information on a bill, we saw that we could run a report of the bills presented as EDI bills. We could sort them by carrier, by month. And so we did and started checking the bills for overcharges.

It was a tedious process that took the better part of the week, but we found a series of shipments which the carrier had inspected and misrated. In fact, they decided eleven of the shipments were class 200, eleven were class 92.5 and the rest they left at the class 50 shown on the bill of lading. We received photos of the inspection and determined that the class 200 was not correct, but decided the class 92.5 was probably correct. For this customer, they get an FAK rating of class 60.

On another EDI bill, it was rated as an expedited freight bill although such service was not requested on the bill of lading. Likewise, we noticed that the bill of lading said the first item was nine cartons weighing 4065 lbs on one pallet. Being familiar with this client's freight, we didn't think they had freight that heavy. Sure enough, the shipment only weighed 406 lbs. We've now filed a claim to get more than $1100 back for this client and their sales representative concurred and sent a note to their Overcharge Claims Department clearing the bill for a refund.

EDI is a tremendous tool for receiving freight bills quickly and allow for an audit, but such audits should always be follow up with a post auditing such as we perform. I always tell prospective clients that every time I think I've seen every way possible for a mistake to happen, we see a new way. And we've been doing this for thirty years now.

Give us a call to talk about how we can recover such overcharges for you!

Friday, April 17, 2009

Celebrating 30 years! Traffic Services of Cinti

This year marks the 30th anniversary of the founding of Traffic Services of Cinti, Inc. I had been working for my dad's business, Jayanel Associates (a name referencing my parents' initials "J" and "L" for Jerry & Loretta) and it became clear that the business could not sustain the staff he had. I took over the freight bill auditing and transportation consulting portion of the business. I was renting a three bedroom house across from my present home and had two spare bedrooms; my first offices!

Besides the freight bill audit accounts, I had several companies I did consulting for, mostly printing companies that need to be able to get rate quotations and freight costs before motor carriers rate clerks came to work in the afternoon. They would call me to get the freight charges so they could set up their billing or their sales department would call to add freight costs into their estimates. This was a year before the first foray into the deregulation of the trucking industry with the Motor Carrier Act of 1980 (which, if I remember correctly, took effect exactly one year later on July 1, 1980). All carriers rates were essentially the same and we subscribed to the many different volumes of the carrier rate bureaus. We had scores of tariffs shelved in the one room and each day we'd receive more supplements to those tariffs.

It's been a long time since I've written a blog entry and I'll add more as the anniversary date approaches. It will be interesting to write about all the changes that have occurred in the trucking business and the freight auditing business over the last thirty years.

Wednesday, March 5, 2008

Bolstering the bottom line

There was a good article in this month's Logistics Management magazine titled 5 Challenges You Can't Ignore by Brent Wm. Primus. Primus talks about various areas of transportation that the astute shipper needs to be attentive to - some very good advice in the piece, so check out the article.



The purpose of my blog today though is to highlight a chart in the article originally developed by the great Bill Augello, a transportation attorney who wrote prolifically about transportation law. He passed away in November, 2006, a great loss for the transportation industry. I had the privileged on a number of occasions to meet Bill and to talk with him over the phone. He was passionate about educating shippers and receivers about transportation law so they could make the best decisions in their ongoing shipping transactions.

The chart Augello created showed the amounts one needed to capture from the dollar losses of a claim. It's startling how a minor claim requires a sizeable sale to recover the lost revenue incurred by the uncollected loss or damage claim.


A good example is in the area of claims management and recovery. Figure 1, prepared by Bill Augello, illustrates the importance of recovering claims for loss and damage and shows how unrecoverable claims can erode a company’s profitability. Unfortunately I can't reproduce the chart here, but it is in the article linked above.

Basically, money overpaid to your carriers is money that is being taken from your bottom line. The chart shows, for instance, that a loss of $500 would require sales equal to $10,000 to make up that lost money (based on a 5% net profit margin). So if we recover a $1000 from one of your carriers, that would be equivalent to a sale of $20,000 under the same scenario. Our overcharge recoveries for you are nothing but an addition to your bottom line. As we state on our website, we have recovered millions of dollars for our clients over the years.

Check with us for our freight bill auditing service - your bottom line will thank you!

Thursday, February 28, 2008

Waiting for Godot? New Year's Work...


Well, we're not actually waiting for Godot (the title of a Samuel Beckett play), unless, of course, Godot is an accountant working for one of our clients!


In the freight bill auditing business, we often have a lag auditing bills in the first month or two of the new year. An email to a client asking them to send their next batch of freight bills to us for audit brought the standard response, "We're waiting for our auditors to finish with their work and then we'll send them right to you." I'll give them another call today and hopefully they will have closed out their year and we can get right on their bills.


It's not always that way - we have many clients who have their Freight Payment provider ship their bills to us each week. For those clients, we often do the audit and place their bills into storage boxes and send the bills on to them ready for their Records Retention department (or arrange for their Records Storage company to pick them up). It does give us regular ongoing work, while we wait for Godot or Smith or Kowalsky to finish the bookkeeping for the other clients!


If your accountants have finished the year end work, why not give us a call and make arrangements for us to do a post audit of your freight bills for you. We continue to find mistakes even after payment audits. We'd love to have the chance to bring some of your money back to you.




Friday, November 2, 2007

Dotting your i's and crossing your t's

I had a conversation this afternoon with a client about a problem we were having collecting an overcharge for them. They had some Pallet Rates published for their freight, both inbound and outbound. Unfortunately the carrier's pricing only named one location - 1070 Main Street, whereas this freight was delivered to them at 1067 Main Street. The carrier was refusing to honor the pricing because that address wasn't listed in their Pricing Agreement with the customer. I was directed to contact their sales representative to ask him to pursue a "business management decision".

I called the rep and told him I thought it was silly to have to jump through hoops to get the pricing applied when the freight was clearly routed based on this pricing. I continue to wonder why carriers who began business in a heavily regulated environment that permitted no deviation from the published and filed rates are unable to operate in the fully deregulated environment. In any other business, if a price was agreed to for a particular customer, the invoice would be corrected if one location was overlooked or they had additional street numbers (as this client does).

The client had called me back to tell me they had only one building - the entire facility was in one building. The two addresses were a vestige of its original construction where the developer could divide the building for two companies if necessary.

I sympathize with a carrier's desire to rate things correctly in the first place; to set in their computer system the information it needs to do that. But the reality is, sometimes every contingency isn't known (or someone doesn't think to say we've got two street numbers here). It's one of the reasons that I've suggested clients write language in their contracts that essentially says "when XYZ Corporation pays the bill, this pricing will apply." No "ifs", "ands" or "buts" - keep it simple.

Thursday, November 1, 2007

We Make Your Carriers Better

It's a hazard of our work as freight bill auditors that we help your carriers rate your bills correctly. I was reminded of this today when one of my staff told me she spoke to one small carrier who we had filed an overcharge claim against. Our claim for a bit over $100 had prompted them to review the client's other bills and they had found other overcharges too. So instead of recovering about $113 for them, the carrier is sending them a check for $1374!
Not only that, but now they will probably not make that mistake again.

We had one account we began auditing a few years ago and one carrier was regularly charging their standard Liftgate charge. The problem was their contract named a different charge and the carrier was overlooking that. We filed claim correcting those bills and recovered that money for the client. Now the carrier rarely misses that contractual charge - an added benefit which costs our customer nothing.

Give us a call to discuss how we can make your carriers better with our freight bill audit.

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Are Overcharges on Freight Bills Really Prevalent?

Are overcharges prevalent? For many years, we sent an article to prospective clients from Colin Barrett's old Questions & Answers columns from Traffic World magazine titled The Need for Auditing Services. In the answer he mentioned a book he and J.S. Traunig wrote about paying freight bills.

There he wrote, "we offered evidence indicating that the aggregate amount of such overpayments may add up to as much as one percent of the entire U.S. Gross National Product!"

I don't know if that number holds up today some twenty plus years later, but as I've said, every time I think I've seen every way possible for a mistake to be made, we find another. ***

Contact us for more information about our Freight Bill Auditing service.

*** Just to highlight this statement, when I was reviewing a client's bills this afternoon, I found a bill with a Fuel Surcharge at 814.96% - a mistake their freight payment company caught (no good for me!), but I wondered where that percentage number came from. It was the Contract number they had with this carrier. Like I said, you never know what you're going to see. The bill was a $796.88 overcharge.

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Inspected Shipment - Bumping up the Weight

This may be a bit obscure, but I've been encouraging my clients to add a clause to their contracts that requires a carrier to bump up the weight of a shipment subject to a class rating based on density when that shipment is inspected.

Item 171 in the NMFC states articles rated by density and make reference to that item may have their weight "bumped" up to secure a lower rating. For instance, a shipment which has a density of 3.60 lbs. PCF (class 250) can have its cube multiplied by 4 lbs. PCF and bump the weight up to receive a class 150 rating. That bumping of the weight is required to be noted on the Bill of Lading at the time of the shipment.

The problem comes when carriers' Weight & Inspection departments inspect a shipment which shows one density and find it's a different density. Many times, shippers calculate their density based on the packaged product whereas the carriers are determining the density based on how it is palletized for shipment. That is correct but it reaps a considerable windfall for the carriers. Understandably, carriers are hoping for that "Gotcha" shipment as their revenue goes up, needless to say.

Some years ago, we wrote a clause into a client's contract to buffer this effect. The provision stated that if a carrier inspects the shipment and finds that the density is incorrect, they are required to bump the weight up to secure the lower rate. Other clients have also used the same language.

This is very "outside the box", but I think more companies should consider this approach. The benefits are clear for shippers who have this language.

Here's an example from yesterday. A client's supplier shipped six pallets of plastic drums without any formal NMFC description, showing a total weight of 1800 lbs. The carrier inspected the goods and found it had a cube of 469.44 Cubic Feet for a density of 3.83 lbs. PCF at class 250.

Ironically, the bill was rated as 2000 lbs. and if you used that weight, the density would be 4.26 lbs. PCF. Of course, that's not how it's done. Using the bumping clause language for inspected shipments, the weight would bump to 1878 lbs. and move at the same 2000 lbs. rate albeit at a class 150 rate. In this case, it would reduces the bill by more than half.

As you can see such language in your contract can control your freight costs a great deal.

Besides our Freight Bill Auditing service we provide consulting to review your contracts and make recommendations to improve them - helping you keep your transportation expense down.

Check us out at http://www.tscinti.com/

Monday, October 29, 2007

No need for an audit?

I was reading an article in the October 2007 issue of Logistics Management magazine by Ray Bohman about Cube based LTL pricing. The article looks at an alternative to the standard pricing using class ratings established by the National Motor Freight Classification (NMFC). It was an interesting article and worth reading.

What jumped out at me while reading it was this line: The system is also designed to eliminate freight bill auditing by outside firms. While I understand what the system's creators are getting at, I would suggest that there is always a need to have someone look at your bills. We have found mistakes under any number of pricing systems, whether class rated shipments under the NMFC; mileage rates, flat rates. As I said in my initial post on this blog, as long as human beings are pressing the buttons, there will be mistakes. Simpler rating systems might reduce the possible ways mistakes can happen, I don't think they will ever go away completely.


Friday, October 26, 2007

Our Freight Bill Auditing Service

For some time I have contemplated starting a blog to highlight some of the work I do as a Transportation Consultant and as a Freight Bill Auditor. I started my firm in 1979 after working some years for a company my father founded. I took over the auditing and consulting side of Dad's business and he continued working directly with trucking companies.

So who needs freight bill auditing? Anyone who ships and receives freight and pays the bill will find our services valuable. The introductory line at the top of the blog remains true: Every time I think I've seen every way possible for a mistake to be made, I find another! These mistakes can made by either the carrier or the customer.

Some years ago, as the move to personal computers was underway, a carrier rep came in and gave me a rate diskette. He asked, "Won't this put you out of business?". I laughed and told him not as long as human beings are pressing the buttons!

I will update the blog periodically. I hope you enjoy my thoughts on this subject. Feel free to ask me any questions!

Many years ago, I read an article in a magazine about what was then the second oldest written document - a clay cuneiform tablet. Archaeologists determined it was a bill of lading - and it had a mistake on it! The livestock were added up incorrectly.

The moral of the story? Mistakes will always happen and we're here to help recover your money when they happen on your freight bills.

I will add posts as time goes by, not just on the adventures of freight bill auditing, but also some of my thoughts on controlling your freight costs too.

In the mean time, check out our website at http://www.tscinti.com/